Which of the panels is better and more informative on the site?

Question

Design

Hello
, there was a need on the site at the top to organize a brief output of the
information necessary for average users, preferably in the form of a panel.
We implemented 2 options and would like to know which one seems more convenient for you:
1. Initially collapsed panel that, when clicked, shows maximum information approximately like livejournal (option 1)
2. Panel displaying 3 news one by one cyclically and weather with exchange rates (option 2)
Thank you for your valuable opinion and we would love to hear your opinions or advice.
Option 1:

Option 2:

Answer 1

Why not merge?
The second option with the possibility of disclosure.

Answer 2

The first option is similar to various kinds of contextual advertising, so people who have been online will ignore it, IMHO

Answer 3

More people will pay attention to the second option, IMHO. However, be sure to provide the opportunity to close this panel, say, with a cross.

Answer 4

I don’t know about your usability experts or yourself, but I try to adhere to one opinion: a person should always have information about the state of the system in front of his eyes.
In other words, the panel from the second option is required . At the same time, it can be combined with the first panel: remove the tab, put the arrows in the middle of the panel of the second option and when you click on the panel, slide out the rest of the panel. Although I'm teaching you. The meaning, I think, is clear.

Answer 5

I would do the first option, but change the behavior a bit: when entering the page, the panel is expanded, after a few seconds it collapses (it is desirable that it be on top of the main content of the page) - the user has time to get an idea of ​​\u200b\u200bwhat is there (unlike the first option ), but you don’t need to make an extra click so that it doesn’t make your eyes callous (unlike the second one). Moreover, such behavior can attract additional emotionally positive attention to it, and the scrolling lines on the pages (and even more so in the statusbar :) ) annoy many, including me, although they also attract attention.

Answer 6

I need your opinion

The title of the question is idiotic and annoying. if a person writes in Q&A, then it is obvious that he "needs our opinion." It was possible to name a topic somehow more constructively?

Answer 7

I agree with the people, I don’t read the first option on the machine.

Answer 8

The second option is better in my opinion. And a cross to close the panel.