M
M
Michio -2018-12-17 10:48:33
Virtualization
Michio -, 2018-12-17 10:48:33

What to choose for virtualization of Intel vs AMD (haper-v/virtual box) windows machines?

It is necessary to deploy an environment of 10 virtual machines on different versions of WIndows with different roles.
On average, one virtual machine requires 2 processors and 2-3 GB of RAM.
We decided to stop at a 2-computer configuration. That is, buy 2 computers and run 5 virtual machines on each.
We select hardware and the question arose of what to take:
Ryzen 7 (8/16) with built-in video + 32 GB of RAM + 3 SSDs in Raid 5 for machines + ssd for the
intel i5 system (6/12) + 32 GB of RAM + 3 SSDs in Raid 5 for machines + ssd for the system
The budget is in favor of Ryzen by 15-20%
As a hypervisor there will be either Haper-v or Windows Server.
Perhaps in the future it will be necessary to forward video cards or other pci-e devices to virtual machines
. Have there been any problems with virtualization on AMD

Answer the question

In order to leave comments, you need to log in

3 answer(s)
D
Dmitry, 2018-12-17
@Tabletko

It is easier to immediately buy a server platform

O
Oleg Kotov, 2018-12-17
@AgeofCreations

Must not be. I would even say that AMD is better suited for this.

V
VoidVolker, 2018-12-18
@VoidVolker

Take EPYC or Threadripper and preferably with ECC memory - more stability, less chance of failure. The more memory, the greater the chance of error. Do not save on memory - Windows with a large amount of memory works noticeably faster than with constant swapping, even with an SSD.
SSD - at least Samsung 970 PRO M2, and better enterprise solutions from the same Samsung or Intel. It makes sense to put in a raid only in a mirror for reliability, but still, an enterprise plus a regular backup rule and looks more reasonable. Dedicating a separate SSD for the system does not make much sense. If you also want file storage, you can use FreeNAS - earlier it was easy to put VirtualBox in jail right out of the box, as it is now - you don’t know. It out of the box supports dual caching in RAM / SSD and a bunch of other cool features.
I have been using virtualbox on amd for a long time - everything is fine.

Didn't find what you were looking for?

Ask your question

Ask a Question

731 491 924 answers to any question