Which chair is more comfortable, saddle chair or knee chairs?

Question

Work organization

Anyone have experience with these chairs? Your opinion?
chair saddle

knee chair

Answer 1

Should I buy a knee stool?
How to treat IT people's backs?
My opinion - take a stool and spend the rest on the gym
With any program that will include squat, bench press, dead lift (or their variations)
When you earn extra couple of money - find a store and sit on herman miller
* without stopping going to the gym ofk

Answer 2

So far, nothing better than a good anatomical office chair has been invented.
All these miracle chairs serve only one purpose - to put a person in conditions where he simply cannot sit crookedly askew, as he used to. Everything else is sacrificed for this purpose.
You can sit straight on a stool, or you can sit straight in a comfortable chair.
To whom as, I personally for the second.
If you retrain yourself to sit normally - then you will not need a saddle or a knee chair - and your back will thank you for normal posture and a comfortable chair and relaxation throughout the day.

Answer 3

I have an intervertebral hernia, it is very difficult to work at a regular office for more than an hour. Now I work standing up mixed with a saddle chair, when I get tired I rest lying down. The back holds marathons at 14 o'clock)) I am very pleased with the chair, after standing it seemed very comfortable))

Answer 4

I tried the HÅG Capisco 8106 saddle - it was awesome, I will take it for myself.
Well, they write correctly - the main thing is alternation. A table with a lift greatly simplifies everything, from time to time you work while standing.

Answer 5

They say that men are uncomfortable in the saddle.
On the knee, my knees start to hurt if the joints are fragile or there were problems before.
If there is a problem with the joints - take a saddle, no - knee.

Answer 6

I have back problems, I tried both of them for about a week - my back was in shock, but the pain was less from the saddle.
Now I have been using the semi-lounger for a month now.

Answer 7

Buy a regular chair with a back and don't worry

Answer 8

Take a regular hardwood chair with a hard back. Well, if you wish, you can also buy a buckwheat podzhopnik