S
S
Sergey2019-02-17 11:24:38
System administration
Sergey, 2019-02-17 11:24:38

What are the methods for isolating users inside Vlan (Mikrotik)?

Several Mikrotik CSR3xxx switches are available. I won’t describe the architecture in detail, but let’s say there is 1 router (mikrotik), a distribution switch (mikrotik) is connected to it, to which, in turn, several more switches (mikrotik) are connected. Clients are already connected directly to these switches. All equipment processes 5 vlans to isolate one client group from another. And here the question arises - how to isolate one user of the vlan from the rest, while leaving them inside one external vlan? And on top of that, without the need to configure client hardware.
Now I'm thinking in the direction of QinQ, but there are problems with setting up the equipment - a tagged frame passes through the port and receives a second tag - everything is fine here, but for this you need to configure vlanes on the client. It has not yet been possible to turn untagged traffic into 2 vlans on the Mikrotik port.
Ordinary segmentation by ports will not help, since clients will see each other on the distribution switch. There is an option with Private vlan, but I did not find setup manuals for Mikrotik. What other options are there? This is already a question rather for general development, since vlans on the equipment are far from 4k, you can just make another vlan, but I would very much like to leave some kind of hierarchy in the network

Answer the question

In order to leave comments, you need to log in

2 answer(s)
V
Valentin, 2019-02-17
@vidikon

This is a bad scenario, LAN is for that and LAN, so that hosts communicate freely inside it (at the network level). If you still need to limit, then
1) QinQ, vlan per port, the second tag on aggregation, remove both on the router
2) L2TP/PPPoE/IPoE per user, on the port-isolate switch
3) ACL on the poppy address, allow only broadcast and Gateway

A
athacker, 2019-02-17
@athacker

Private VLAN, aka port isolation for micro: https://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Manual:Switch_Chip_...

Didn't find what you were looking for?

Ask your question

Ask a Question

731 491 924 answers to any question