Thematic collective blog: Wordpress + Buddypress or LiveStreet?

Question

CMS

At the moment there is a small blog on Wordpress. There is a desire to make a habra-like collective blog out of it.

I understand that LiveStreet is purposefully geared towards community blogging, but has anyone made a direct comparison to Buddypress? What is the fundamental difference?

There is no particular desire to code or customize very deeply (at least for now).

Answer 1

LiveStreet

Answer 2

wordpress - constantly updated, reliable.
livestreet - not ok with updates. a bunch of paid plugins, which are then slaughtered by their creators. there is no single command. the creator of livestreet himself constantly, every year, releases a new version of the dvigla lodge its long on everyone else, a bunch of add-ons disappear immediately. and half of them are no longer updated at all, because the creators simply scored, disappeared. so there's a lot of crap. BUT, of course, the functionality is better than WP, if you buy 10-15k plugins, you can safely make your own habr;)

Answer 3

When I had a similar choice, I chose LS, but it is possible that now, most likely, I would have acted differently.
The advantages of WP are simply a huge community and the number of plugins, with LS everything is more complicated. There's a lot to figure out and figure out. If this does not scare, then LS is also possible. If there is no desire to code and customize, then WP is better. IMHO, of course.
You also need to understand what you need from a CMS. LS already has a built-in rating and rating system, and in WP, as far as I remember, it was necessary to install some plugins and finish the functionality. Well and further in such spirit. Clearly define the requirements for the CMS and dance from this.
When moving, pay special attention to layout and redirects, because the url structure in these CMS is different. Personally, my traffic sank 1.5 times. And only now, after almost a year, he began to recover. In general, WP is more SEO friendly.
By the way, about the url structure. in LS and in WP. In WP, a post is unlinked from any category and it can be published in several at once (as in Habré - hubs), in LS, a specific post is tied to a blog, because the blog name is included in the URL. This, in my opinion, is not very good. And if you later want to move the post to another blog? Or will the site structure need to be changed? In general, there will not be enough blood here. In WP, everything is quite simple.
In general, there is something to think about.
PS: what happened to me, you can look here .

Answer 4

Chose tsms for a collective blog. I drove the following:
- BuddyPress
- LiveStreet
- Cogear
- InstantCMS
- vBulletein
Stopped at InstantCMS.

Answer 5

And who would choose what now?
Both a collective blog and static pages (articles, calculators, catalog) are required