S
S
StrangeAttractor2012-10-17 03:25:08
Hard disks
StrangeAttractor, 2012-10-17 03:25:08

Rhetorical question: when marking an external hard into one large partition, is it better to make it primary or logical?

I mark up a new two-terabyte railway for a portable "file dump". To be on it one large partition, most likely NTFS (so that you can come with it to a friend and connect it to his Windows computer without any problems) with some large (16 or 32 KB) sector size. Attention a question: it is better to make this section logical or primary?

A long time ago, in a galaxy far , far awayin the days of Windows 98 and earlier, the answer was unequivocally "logical" since the system put all primary partitions in front of logical ones, and if there was a primary partition on the brought hard, then it stuck in front of partition D of the main railway. Now this reason is gone, but subjectively the hand still reaches out to make the non-system partition logical, while common sense seems to say that with less than 4 partitions on the disk, logical partitions are not needed.

Are there any more or less objective arguments in favor of this or that option?

Answer the question

In order to leave comments, you need to log in

4 answer(s)
A
Andrey Burov, 2012-10-17
@BuriK666

Primary only. A logical partition is, roughly speaking, a partition within a partition.

A
Alexander Lebedev, 2012-10-17
@cawaleb

Do the main one, although it is not very clear what demons have to do with it. I quote:
> come with him to a friend and connect to his without any problems ...

N
nochkin, 2012-10-17
@nochkin

There was no such problem in the days of Windows 98 (I can’t say about distant galaxies), always the only partitions were primary.
If the drive is not a system drive, then it can be reassigned. It does not depend on the partition type.

A
agmt, 2012-10-17
@agmt

Considering that the beginning of the partition will be either on the 64 or 2048 sector, there will be enough space to make it temporarily logical as a last resort =)
And one more question after that: given that 2TB is the limit for an MBR with a classic 512b sector, how what about the MBR with 4kb sector?

Didn't find what you were looking for?

Ask your question

Ask a Question

731 491 924 answers to any question