Is indexing comments important for SEO?

Question

Search Engine Optimization

There is such a service for external comments - https://tolstoycomments.com.
He has a lot of plushies.
As a result, visitor engagement increases.
But there is a significant disadvantage - comments are not indexed and are not stored in the database.
Therefore, the question arises - which is better - engagement or indexing of comments?
For example, a blog has 1,000-10,000 comments per month. Will it greatly affect SEO positions if there is / will not be indexing?

Answer 1

It depends on what will be in the comments, if meaningful texts are at least a paragraph long, then it can be indexed, if phrases like Agon, Bugaga, Oru are like a howitzer, then it’s not worth it.

Answer 2

Better engagement. Indexed comments are certainly super, but pf in Yandex play a much larger role.

Answer 3

Depends on how interesting texts you have in the comments

Answer 4

Comments are content. If the content is interesting and meaningful, then this is only good. Better engagement and indexing. However, the question here is how much the indexed text dilutes the main text.

Answer 5

It's impossible to say for sure. Everyone chooses something. I would choose indexing, because. comments can make a big difference.
But it works in the following way - promotion is not for the requests you are interested in, but for additional ones. For example, in the text, the number of occurrences is already approaching overspam, or you simply can’t organically enter requests. For example, typos. But in the comments it is ideal to use.
And in terms of behavior - people will still write and leave comments, I think. Maybe less, but still.

Answer 6

In terms of seo, of course - this is DAMN your content! Don't give it to anyone!!!