A
A
akosarev2010-12-16 04:00:32
Hard disks
akosarev, 2010-12-16 04:00:32

Choosing a file system for an external HDD (Linux + Windows)?

Good afternoon dear community!
I often have this problem: I need to choose a file system for an external drive, which then will need to be connected for reading and writing on several machines with different OS: Linux (mainly Ubuntu) and Windows (7, possibly XP).
This issue is caused by repeated data loss when writing to non-native FS ... FS
requirements:
* reliability;
* support for exotic (Chinese, Japanese, Korean, etc.) filenames;
* 500 GB disk support.
I think the answer to this question will be useful not only to me.
Thank you!

Answer the question

In order to leave comments, you need to log in

9 answer(s)
M
marcus, 2010-12-16
@marcus

So after all, the NTFS-3G driver is included in Linux distributions by default, so NTFS.

V
Vlad Zhivotnev, 2010-12-16
@inkvizitor68sl

And again I remind you about UFS ...

A
ahromenko, 2010-12-16
@ahromenko

I carry a 320 GB puller with me, the NTFS system, it works everywhere, both in Ubuntu and on Windows

X
xackep, 2010-12-16
@xackep

As a linux user, I chose the following option for myself: I
split the disk into two parts, 100 MB under fat32 on which there are ext drivers for Windows, everything else is ext3

S
stampoon, 2010-12-16
@stampoon

NTFS or ext3/ext2 + small fat partition with driver for wine

S
Sergey, 2010-12-16
@bondbig

habrahabr.ru/qa/2298/

F
FeNUMe, 2010-12-16
@FeNUMe

Unfortunately, there are no options yet - NTFS. The reason for this is naturally Windows, for which, although there are plug-ins for working with ext *, they are either paid or work out of the ordinary badly. At the same time, Linux has been working pretty well with NTFS for a long time. Although I don’t argue, there is a bug - every time the same torrent is rehashed for vin and lin - 100% on Windows, 99.8% on Linux (tested on several dozen torrents from 1 to 15gb), I used to sin on the alpha utorrent for linux, but now I'm thinking that it could be NTFS problems. Interestingly, even at 99.8%, the files are still completely readable - videos are played, archives are unpacked (without information for recovery), toys / software are installed ...
Well, if you don’t transfer files larger than 4GB on a screw, then the old FAT32 can serve you :)

D
Dmitry Sidorov, 2010-12-16
@Doomsday_nxt

I have a flash drive in FAT32, due to the fact that a friend's home theater and a radio tape recorder in a car do not know other file systems ... Although for a radio tape recorder you would need to buy a separate flash drive :-)
And yes, in FAT, only the maximum file size limit worries me (images You can't drag DVD :-))

P
pentarh, 2010-12-16
@pentarh

fat does not roll in terms of limiting the maximum file size.
*niks FS do not roll, because Without additional hemorrhoids, Windows will not see them.
And Windows knows nothing more. So NTFS.

Didn't find what you were looking for?

Ask your question

Ask a Question

731 491 924 answers to any question