Are backlinks important when choosing drop domains?

Question

Search Engine Optimization

Chose 2 good domains.
One has about 300 backlinks from various news sources, published on various material sites, etc., look natural. But the site on the domain was of a different theme, and regional. Links also do not correspond to the new topic.
The second one has nothing.
Dropped more than a year ago, nothing left in the search.
Which of the domains is better to choose for further promotion, and why?

Answer 1

In the current case, the first drop with backlinks is certainly better, at least it will transfer weight. The second one has neither traffic nor links, this is a dummy.

Answer 2

Well, for their sake, they usually take it, and the second is a beautiful name
. If the topic is left, it’s better to take a new domain, boost from search engines at the start will give more traffic than using the old domain

Answer 3

There is not enough data to answer your question definitively.
On the one hand, the quality of the backs is important, on the other hand, the theme.
In general, low-quality backs or backs of other subjects can contribute to falling under various filters.
And remember that now is not 2008, the search engines are no longer stupid, and they perfectly understand that a new site on the drop is a new site that has nothing to do with the old one
. Therefore, it often makes sense to use a new domain, there are fewer risks, tk. fewer external factors beyond your control, and everything depends on you.