T
T
Tom Nolane2017-05-01 13:53:25
Toaster
Tom Nolane, 2017-05-01 13:53:25

Should one-day toaster one-questioners be banned from asking questions?

Good day toaster and tochterchanki!
Question/suggestion.
On Toster.ru there are often people who ask only 1 question, get (or sometimes do not get) an answer, do not mark (mark) anything and leave ... without returning.
So, I have a question / suggestion: can a one-day (who has just registered) enter "a la" as in habrahabr - "inferior accounts"? - so that they (let's say) first answer 10 questions themselves (for example), after which their account goes into "full" and can already ask their own questions?
This is all for what: there is a search (both on the toaster and on other services) and just like that - they don’t look for answers that were given earlier, but for the millionth time (every day) they ask questions from the category of “what to do junu in php"
Answers to such questions have long been given (and quite cool answers), nevertheless, they still ask, and disappear ... Thus, they "flood" (my IMHO). Those who gave several answers on the toaster - basically know how to use the search, and if they don’t find it, then they already ask a question.
How do you think?
UPD

spoiler
dc2be195cca346d1a2ad614dc5b7f28f.PNG42df37cdfa3f47c487ba2dc91cb6709f.PNG7def8f85b85642a3a6c9f254c77835e2.PNG9b98060640ad4f5d941c07cb66588b26.PNG
UPD2!!!!
877a21ddb2ff4df3ab68425370d9b46b.PNG
UPD 3
about the "favorite" of some stackoverflows
61f5ed7437e149b69ebf875471fd41c6.PNG

At the moment (I personally heard the following) what would help the toaster (or not enough):
1) the majority is against the introduction of pre-moderation (answer 10 questions and ask yourself)
2) there is not enough "dislike" button
3) an interesting suggestion - add a FAQ for the most common questions (what should junu %JP% do, or "how to install a theme on wordpress", etc.)
4) maybe a reminder from above? about the magic button "complain" (if the question is not a question one)
5) allow moderators (experienced in the topic) to mark (once a month / two) - questions that were answered (correct if the answers) - mark as a decision (if the author of the question is one-day-old or has not been on the toaster for a very long time: a year / two /three conditionally) - and delete questions - for which there is no answer and the questions themselves are outdated (for example, "what's new in php4.x version?")
6) introduction of an analogue of "reputation"

Answer the question

In order to leave comments, you need to log in

11 answer(s)
Z
Zelimkhan Beltoev, 2017-05-01
@tomnolane

Think 10 useless answers are better than one useless question?
In addition, there are enough such answers even without beginners, and with such rules, a toaster can turn into a trash can in general

S
Site Developer, 2017-05-01
@secsite

Thus, they "flood" (my IMHO)

They do not flood, but fill the toaster with content :)
The quality of this content is a separate question and is in no way connected with the number of questions and answers.
It's stupid to force an answer before asking a question. The smart ones will simply go to another resource, and the stupid ones will be so stupid .. That's where the flood will be.

I
ivleva_m, 2017-05-01
@ivleva_m

So so idea.

V
V Sh., 2017-05-02
@JuniorNoobie

I understand that the author is not so much concerned that newcomers ask questions, but that their questions "litter" his feed. As an option, make the feed settings more flexible: show questions only from those authors who have asked more than N questions, show only those questions that have gained N subscribers, and so on.
So that the questions are not repeated, it is enough to complain about the question. Especially for this, the "Complaint" button is made. Forbidding newcomers to ask questions is nonsense. Nine simple questions are sometimes asked one that will be of interest to many.

S
Sergey, 2017-05-01
@edinorog

Imagine... three in the morning! ... at the person the server lay down!!!! raid not working!!!!! he is in a panic .. google where to ask a question .... and in addition to registering he has to wait until he manages to answer 10 questions?)

A
AlikDex, 2017-05-02
@AlikDex

Firstly. This question is from the category of provocative and is aimed exclusively at boltology. Violates the rules of the resource and does not apply to its subject. Those. the author should be banned for this, karma reset, and the account deleted. This is at least. Banned by IP to the heap and sent out of the country.
Secondly. For brilliant ideas, there is a feedback form with a special mark "brilliant idea". Learned to use the search, but not the rest of the functions? Well, who are you after that?

X
xtala zen, 2017-05-02
@xtala

Shave your mustache under your nose more often, do not comb your bangs to the side, and your mental state will improve.

V
vasIvas, 2017-05-02
@vasIvas

A person who asks "how to add 2 + 2" is most likely just looking at programming and it's normal that he has one question. A person who asks what an isomorphic application is cannot be a beginner, because the level of such questions requires certain knowledge. But this knowledge will not be enough to return again and again and not ask a question.
In my opinion, questions more complicated than a sandbox in a single instance are asked by bots that create the appearance of a resource's life. If, for example, they were forced to write simple questions so as not to arouse suspicion, then for the resource this would mean one hundred of its content is primitive, which means that the resource itself is not interesting. The golden mean is to ask medium-topical questions that people are interested in.
And everything is fine until you realize what you are reading or trying to help the bot. That's when you start to think about the waste of time and the attitude of the creators towards you.
If the creators really do this, then I want to convey to them that this is bad and very noticeable to experienced people who should settle on resources raising their prestige. But there is also the possibility that these are competing pests. How good it is to shit, and then subtly hint around only bots and all visitors are wasting their time.
Although there is a possibility that this is a double divorce of the creators themselves, who are pushing for a paid help resource. How else to close access to bots and make high quality questions? Of course to impose a bribe! Mzdets...

I
Ivan Zheludkov, 2017-05-01
@webvany

It is necessary for newcomers to social advertising on the main page. Good.

S
Stopy, 2017-05-02
@Stopy

I propose to add the ability to complain about a question if it does not meet certain rules (for example, answered 100 times on a toaster), a moderator comes to the complaints and decides what to do with the impudent.

G
gleendo, 2017-05-02
@evgeniy8705

That's a job for the moderators... They kind of have to moderate the questions before they open the question to the audience. Even this question should not have been moderated... The
question leads to discussion.

Didn't find what you were looking for?

Ask your question

Ask a Question

731 491 924 answers to any question