Does the quality of mobile communication depend on the quality of the Internet in the area?

Question

Computer networks

There was a dispute. I believe that the quality of communication depends on the quality of the Internet in the area. Opponent does not agree with this.
Judge us. Preferably with examples

Answer 1

on the contrary, this is the Internet (mobile) depends on mobile communications because the Internet goes through mobile communications and not vice versa. Mobile communications do not care about the Internet.

Answer 2

No, it doesn't. Rather, the quality of the Internet directly depends on the quality of mobile communications.

Answer 3

The Internet does not exist at all. There is a global network in which there is no concept of "quality" according to the concepts of the inhabitants.

Answer 4

They correctly write to you that the better the connection, the better the Internet. The speed also depends on many other factors:
- availability of 2G, 3G and 4G base station coverage;
- the presence of a transport channel (from the BS) of the required capacity;
- Availability of free timeslots. Voice priority;
- characteristics of the final equipment
- other factors.

Answer 5

Does not depend. The last mile for the provider. The backbones can be the same, but the quality of the providers is different. Hardly a problem on the highway.
The voice is even more in tenth place.

Answer 6

As a rule, in any area of ​​any large city - there are several providers (unless they have already merged in complete ecstasy, keeping many names for the species). And the quality of their Internet access can be. very different.
Cellular communication is like another provider. This provider is called "opsos" and provides not only Internet access, but also voice communication; moreover, Internet data and voice go on the same channel; typically, a link is a cable that goes to a cell tower, although radio links can also be used.
If the opsos also provides cable Internet access, then quality correlation is possible, but not required. And the quality of communication - it is with this provider.
---
However, your question can also be understood as "the relationship between the quality of voice communication and the quality of cellular Internet access"
If the quality depends on the quality of the radio channel or on the congestion of cable channels - it can be.
If the quality of the Internet suffers from the poor performance of other providers, then voice communication can. good, but internet access is poor.
In short, everything is complicated. Both voice communication and Internet access provide complex systems from many components. Some of these components are common to voice and the Internet; and some are separate.