Does SEO depend on CMS?

V

Vladimir Proskurin2014-06-23 14:50:36

CMS

Vladimir Proskurin, 2014-06-23 14:50:36

Good afternoon. A rather strange dispute arose among my colleagues and myself. They believe that the indexing of search engines depends on the content management system. i.e. if I am given a laid-out HTML layout, and there is a choice, for example, Joomla or ModX in terms of seo, then the ModX type will be better. But why? After all, the engine gives me only my own layout, with filled-in data such as menus and articles. And even if I throw off the usual static HTML page, it will be indexed no better than the same page stretched on ModX. Tell me how you can prove that indexing does not depend on the CMS. Or am I still wrong?
Thank you!

Reply

Answer the question

In order to leave comments, you need to log in

9 answer(s)

E

Eugene Burmakin, 2014-06-23
@Vlad_IT

No, it's a myth.

Z

zooks, 2014-06-23
@zooks

Depends only indirectly.

V

Viktor Vsk, 2014-06-23
@viktorvsk

Do solar flares affect the Earth's atmosphere?
Sometimes it seems that they really influence, but no one can ever prove this. And fortune-tellers and astrologers will still receive money for being advised to sit at home tomorrow because of these same solar flares.

A

anggyre, 2014-06-23
@anggyre

CMS is selected for a specific task (including SEO), but not vice versa.
If SEO goals are not formulated, it doesn't matter which engine to use.

A

Alexey Medvedev, 2014-06-24
@medvedhack

If you use more popular systems, such as WordPress or Joomla, then there is an incredible number of seo plugins for them, making them more flexible compared to the same ModX. And it really depends. The cms architecture is different, plus headers, plus robot.txt, plus sitemap.xml generation, plus .htaccess with various mod rewrite rules. So it's really a fact that depends. There is finally SEO Monster, for the pop. engines!

D

Dimas123, 2014-06-25
@Dimas123

If you think like you, i.e. cms gives what I want it to give. Then it doesn't matter what cms, if you are able to set it up like that.
If we compare cms out of the box, then yes, some cms are initially better tailored for seo.

S

Sanes, 2014-06-26
@Sanes

The benefit of MODX is that it's easier for you to control your code. Unlike the same Joomla, which with templates and add-ons turns into a frank mess.

I

Igor Timoshenkov, 2014-07-03
@t1gor

It does not depend in any way, because the first (CEO) is the position of the head of the company, and the second (CMS) is the content management system on the site. And even if you meant SEO [Search engines optinization] - it still doesn't matter. Almost every CMS has a set of modules that implement one or another rule/optimization problem.

D

dmitryosipov, 2014-09-08
@dmitryosipov

How to set up a CMS, so it will behave