Choosing cms Joomla vs ModX?

Question

MODX

We are in the process of choosing a CMS for an information resource that will host
Useful articles and reviews on goods and services
News Q&A (Forum) - where users
ask questions, and we answer them publicly text content. What are the requirements for the engine: SEO Friendly Multilingual Ease of work for copywriters Ease of administration Large number of ready-made add-ons Speed ​​Functionality in terms of News and Articles Current choice situation: WordPress is very frightening that it is full of holes and the slowest among the big three (Joomla and Drupal)
Drupal is not user friendly and the code is poorly written. requires a lot of programmer participation
ModX vs Joomla
ModX - they say very user friendly but administer over 1000 articles, it's hard they say
Joomla say terrible in terms of SEO? Duplicate pages?
There are dozens of articles on the net that praise each of the CMS.
The choice was reduced to 2 ModX or Joomla systems.
What are your opinions?
Thanks

Answer 1

Everything you wrote in the requirements is perfect for Wordpress. The main thing is to set it up correctly. You, as is clear from the description, have a blog or a news portal. Joomla is also ideal for your conditions.
For MODx slightly different requirements:
Unlimited ability to implement any design.
Openness of the system for new modules (low cost of ordering new plugins and freelance modules).
Full control over any element of the site and a piece of code.
Opportunity to expand opportunities in the future.
SEO oriented.
Personally, I work for MODx and am very satisfied. I advise.

Answer 2

Definitely MODX. I enjoy working with him every time. True creative freedom!

Answer 3

If you need a fast, safe and high-quality site - I advise MODx, but there will not be a large number of ready-made add-ons. But, on the other hand, if third-party plugins are installed in Joomla without measure, then it will quickly cease to be fast and safe. The Joomla admin panel is more convenient for an ordinary mortal, but in MODx you can customize the admin panel for yourself: create fields, rename, delete unnecessary ones, change the design, you can even create a separate administration panel for content managers, in a word, MODx customization is limited only by imagination and skill specialist.

Answer 4

I would recommend MODX, but it doesn't meet the point of your requirement for a large number of ready-made add-ons. This is a framework with an admin panel. Flexibility and scalability - yes, SEO-oriented and security - yes, but you won’t be able to click on anything by assembling from ready-made modules.
In general, it is not clear how it happened that you dismissed WordPress and Drupal in favor of Joomla)) Most likely, you need a site that non-professionals can build and maintain. But then do not count on stable and fast work, security and solving any problems and tasks. This is provided not by cms, but by people. And cms is just a tool.

Answer 5

Ease of work for copywriters
A large number of ready-made add-ons
Functionality in terms of News and Articles

This is WordPress.
You can do it on MODX, but without experience it will not be easy to start a complex project. Speed ​​up on WP with caching plugins.
Do not consider Joomla at all.