What SCADA system are you using?

Question

Software and Internet Services

Working in the field of automated control systems, I repeatedly used the solution from AdAstra TraceMode version 6. However, work in this system is full of war with bugs (not without reason the first two letters in the name of the company Ad :) ). The system “eats” just a huge number of devices, and implements a sea of ​​\u200b\u200beverything, but stability leaves much to be desired.
There is a completed project on Siemens WinCC version 6.2 - of course, it is much better than the first one, but I caught my troubles.
Now I plan to use their MX with Mitsubishi FX. By the way, who can work? (Pros, cons).
A colleague from another company advises Citrix - he says it is difficult to program, but stable like clockwork.
What system would you recommend? Have you worked with any of the above? Or other?

Answer 1

But you didn't say what the system should work with :) We pump oil, the signals come according to a strictly defined protocol from the lower level, so we don't work directly with the sensors.
The good old Realflex v4.2 is spinning based on the QNX 4 RTOS :) Vostok from EleSy is used as an eavesdropper (rare g *, to be honest). Now we are interested in SCADA for QNX 6 (after all, support for the new hardware in the four is lame). The stations use local SCADA systems from Vira Realtime (I don't remember the name) and iFix (GE Fanuc).

Answer 2

For me, QNX is most likely not an option yet, because to set up the system you need to understand it well ... Is the solution from EleSy integrated with QNX, or do you have to install it yourself?

Answer 3

Wonderware InTouch (in the future + Industrial Application Server). I can’t name any special pluses, but I can live, and I didn’t have to compare it with something else.