What is wrong in the topic?

Talk2012-12-14 08:16:21

Habr

Talk, 2012-12-14 08:16:21

Tonight I posted a completely neutral topic: Link . During the night they downvoted the topic and karma. What is wrong in the topic? This is my first post, and I'm wondering what's wrong with it in order to avoid such errors in the future.

Answer the question

In order to leave comments, you need to log in

8 answer(s)

Antelle, 2012-12-14
@Antelle

I suppose: someone thought that he was considered a fool who did not know where to buy an iPhone without a markup immediately after the appearance; someone just doesn't like Apple; someone is unhappy with the prices and thought it was a veiled advertisement.
Well, -2 - it was not downvoted.

astrobeglec, 2012-12-14
@astrobeglec

They don't ask questions like this on the hub. Karma is the attitude of other users towards you. Moreover, the pros and cons are anonymous, and no one is obliged to report on the pros and cons to karma.
So take it easy.

Mike Grigorieff, 2012-12-14
@Grigorieff

They do not like the iPhone on Habré

barker, 2012-12-14
@barker

So in the morning you did a reset for some reason, the current that there was zero and zero votes. What was the point of doing a one-time reset, and then writing this question. What did they count on? The stated +10 karma you could have, however, only from the previous question with begging for karma a year ago. For there is nothing more. By the way, a year has passed, but where are the podcasts for which you have collected karma?

Puma Thailand, 2012-12-14
@opium

The topic does not carry any technical information, habr is not a bulletin board.
Let's flood the hub with news, we started selling a new Nokia, Samsung, iphone 8, ipad 16.
everyone who needs to buy it abroad, buying in Russia is stupid.

Anakros, 2012-12-14
@Anakros

Everyone is minus, just from the number of pluses, if you liked the article, it's not so noticeable. From a neutral topic in most cases, you can only expect a minus. Especially on the subject of Apple (there are a lot of haters).

elliadan, 2012-12-14
@elliadan

IMHO: the topic looks like an advertisement for the store you linked to.
Maybe that's also why.

VMAtm, 2012-12-14
@VMAtm

Firstly, the news about sales on Habré has already been ( proof ), and recently, and was also downvoted.
Secondly, as already mentioned, the news looks like an advertisement for buying an iPhone through Svyaznoy (with a slight mention of other stores).
Thirdly, as already mentioned, the news is not of a particularly technical nature, and the article, in general, is poorly written (it does not represent a single whole, and calling an iPhone a device is strange, IMHO), and its value even after a month will become doubtful.
It would be better if they did an overview of new features and a crash test.