How to make comments on the site as efficiently as possible, taking into account open id and connection with social networks?

Y

yasha_somov2011-01-11 02:37:31

Open ID

yasha_somov, 2011-01-11 02:37:31

Question to the respected community.

I have a lot of content on my site. It is important to people and they comment on it.
Now registered users and guests can comment (with captcha). There is also a button with buttons (LJ, VK, FB and Twitter)
Example
But I wanted more efficiency from this tool.

That is:

1. Make it more user-friendly
2. Improve integration with social networks.

For the first point, it is logical to add OpenID.
For the second, make discussion threads depending on belonging to the social network. How it's done here .

But if I do both, I get two problems.

1. The user from the Contact will not be able to answer anything to the user from Facebook
2. The user and Google's OpenID will not be able to answer anything to the user from the contact and will be forced to communicate in “their own window / tab”, where the same losers hang out ... (smile)

Maybe there is some more correct solution? What an integration service…
Thanks in advance.

PS I really liked how the 3d news was done. There really discussions grow.

Reply

Answer the question

In order to leave comments, you need to log in

4 answer(s)

S

SMiX, 2011-01-11
@SMiX

Check out disqus.com . Optionally, you can notify friends about comments there.

A

Aidos, 2011-01-11
@Aidos

Have you watched the service - loginza.ru/ ?

Z

zizop, 2011-01-11
@zizop

It is best to do authorization / registration of users through OpenId. For this, loginza.ru is suitable for our social networks, as Aidos correctly noted, for foreign ones - RpxNow.com. At the same time, users will be created in your system based on their profiles in social networks. It is not necessary (and not necessary) to share comments on social networks. All users will be equal. If you are coding in php, I have Zend Framework classes to work with OpenId brokers and providers.

U

uadeveloper, 2011-01-11
@uadeveloper

Personal opinion:
I like resources that have authorization in different services. (and not the Vkontaktovsky or Facebook block for comments, it is not convenient, your comment will appear in the news and all friends will see it, sometimes you don’t want them to see it).
And the page with the article and adding a comment is made on Ajax.
In such cases, I even write a pleasure.